Our new issue is out on Tuesday. Get a $20 discounted print subscription today! Read more Categories News Tags Afghanistan War Crimes - Australian Quakers , alleged war crimes by Australian soldiers in Afghanistan , Brereton Report , Defence and Trad , Joint Parliamentary Committee on Foreign Affairs , Resilient Agriculture and Livelihoods Initiative … As for the inevitable silences – these have to do with the political leadership which took Australia to a war in Afghanistan and maintained the country’s commitment to it long after it had conceivable national defence benefit to Australia. As minister for defense industry from 2016–18, Christopher Pyne helped usher in a $200 billion military spending spree. Within less than a year, reports of sadistic violence started coming out from Afghanistan and later Iraq, and they haven’t stopped appearing since. Reading the Brereton Report’s chilling accounts of murder as a bonding exercise, it’s hard not to remember Chelsea Manning’s 2013 description of the war crimes that led her to blow the whistle as “similar to a child torturing ants with a magnifying glass.” A copy of the Afghanistan Inquiry Report (Public Release Version) is available. The release of the Brereton Report has confirmed an open secret: Australian soldiers in Afghanistan are suspected of murdering at least thirty-nine unarmed civilians. ), How often? Amazon Workers Don’t Need Apologies From Jeff Bezos. The release of the Brereton Report has confirmed an open secret: Australian soldiers in Afghanistan are suspected of murdering at least thirty-nine unarmed civilians. However, the report determined that responsibility for the alleged crimes “does not extend to higher headquarters.” Given that Australian strategists maintain that Clausewitz is to be taken seriously, then Afghanistan is not the place for reckless alliance enthusiasts to unleash “primordial violence, hatred, and enmity, which are to be regarded as a blind natural force; of the play of chance and probability within which the creative spirit is free to roam.”. In addition to the symbolic strengthening of the Australia–United States alliance, the cozy relationship between Australian politicians, big business, and the weapons industry goes some way toward explaining the nation’s involvement in this endless war. She confesses that reading the Brereton report this week was a cathartic feeling. Perhaps the most garish example came in 2019, when Donald Trump pardoned and celebrated Navy SEAL Edward Gallagher — who allegedly boasted of murdering a schoolgirl and other children — as an “ultimate fighter” and “a great warrior.” In similar fashion, former Australian defense minister Brendan Nelson defended a Special Air Service (SAS) soldier accused of murdering a teenager as being “by any standard, one of the greatest Australians in terms of heroism the country’s produced.”. Your contribution will fund quality independent comment and analysis in Pearls and Irritations. But just as often, the crimes were implicitly or explicitly sanctioned by those higher up. Catalyst, a new journal published by Jacobin, is out now. While the Brereton report states that there is evidence of 39 murders, it acknowledges that there were likely more. Weekly, It is risible to see the Australian Foreign Minister setting…. Chris Dite is a teacher and union member. Sadly, the Prime Minister appears complicit in all of this because, well before the release of the report, and presumably anyone's ability to read it, changes were made to the Letters Patent, dated July 13, 2020. But that cannot be the end of it: why was the focus lost? It is, rather, an ideal incubator for the developments which have necessitated the Inspector-General’s investigations. What is the Brereton Report? Specifically, this leadership will never be the subjects of the Office of the Special Investigator or the Australian Federal Police, nor, therefore, will they ever be charged. The predictable consequence for some as the time frame is extended, especially in the elite units and/or those famed for their audacity, and overburdened with dangerous missions requiring exceptional skill, is a process of convergence. They become what they revile and their recourse and refuge is found- in blood-crazed, self-delighting violence which offends even the criminal essence or war in the first place. The investigation was led by Major General Paul Brereton.. Then there is war itself. The Brereton Report: the failure of political and military leadership. Brereton’s recommendation and Campbell’s acceptance of it show even the most unlikely people can forget, or overlook, or ignore, what the rule of law means. Exacerbating this, they were in theatres of operation that were culturally and politically alien, against enemies difficult, if not impossible to distinguish from the general population, and in which the strategic objectives were either fundamentally unclear, unrealistic, or ridiculous. Alongside this rigorous disinformation campaign, Western governments have also worked hard to build a macho media aura around the elite soldiers deployed to fight forever. To accept this is to accept the relevance of a principle in physics which holds that the effect of certain forces – such as light, sound and gravity – on an object varies by the inverse square of the distance between the object and the source of the force until – and here the report modifies physics – the object is out of sight and, therefore, out of mind. Last week, the Brereton Report documented terrible atrocities committed by Australian forces in Afghanistan. The authors of the report have gone to great lengths to stress that these slayings — whose victims include children — were driven by “blood lust,” “competition killing,” and sickening “rites of passage.”, The Australian government this week referred the matter to a special investigator. First, there was the internal report by a sociologist, Dr Samantha Crompvoets, who was originally commissioned to prepare a report on organisational culture and poor relations between the Australian SAS and Commandoes. Eventually, the conviction emerges that victory is a mirage; the campaign, in Yeatsian terms, no more than “a trouble of fools,” and legal constraint an absurdity. Beyond the inevitability of the events which resulted in the Inspector-General’s inquiry, there is also the inevitability of contradictions and silences: the former relate to the confusion between the report’s findings that: “commanders are both recognised and accountable for what happens on their watch,” and bear a moral command responsibility;” that the wrongdoing was widely known and often the subject of gloating by its perpetrators, and yet the higher Defence command system was at not at fault in regard to the commission of war crimes on the grounds that it/they were unaware of them. The Brereton report of Australian SAS warcrimes in Afghanistan reveals how Australia's 'innocent' image is fraudulant, and always was. The higher military  command structures were equally deaf and blind to the warning signs; worse, they might even have ignored them. Human ingenuity is seldom kind to immutable laws and the concept of effects invariably following necessary and sufficient causes is, therefore, best left to explanations of avalanches and earthquakes. Michael McKinley is a member of the Emeritus Faculty, the Australian National University; he taught Strategy, Diplomacy and International Conflict at the University of Western Australia and the ANU. The debate and backlash that will follow these latest revelations will focus on gruesome details and the dubious character of the individuals involved. After just a few months Brereton’s ‘brave’ report slips out of view After the hand-wringing, politics got in the way. They Need to Organize. Add to this, repeated deployments of the special forces units for tasks more appropriately undertaken by conventional formations, combined with no prospect of victory, and the creation is the military equivalent of the realty of both the law of diminishing returns, and mission exhaustion. During his brief tenure, he controversially purchased twenty-four Super Hornet jet fighters from defense giant Boeing for $6 billion. David McBride, the man who is responsible for bringing the current allegations to light, is currently still being prosecuted for his courage. Senior military and political figures confirmed this in originally classified interviews, released last year by the Washington Post. The findings of the Afghanistan Inquiry, then, are no surprise. The investigation was led by Paul Brereton, who is both a New South Wales Supreme Court judge and a major general in the army reserve. Perhaps with greater access for the Australian media, some of the events alleged by the Brereton Report might never have happened. Please keep your comments short and sharp and avoid entering links. Journalism Is in Crisis. The “you scratch my back” culture in the defense industry isn’t limited to politicians. His role? “The Australian government was right to promptly release the Brereton report, and the shocking news that the special forces unlawfully killed 39 … Our new issue, “The Ruling Class” is out on Tuesday. And in recent years, Australian defense ministers have developed a habit of scoring cushy jobs in the private defense sector upon their retirement from public life. Defense industry giants like Thales donate generously every year to both the Labor and Liberal parties. Given the seriousness of the findings made in the Brereton report, “show cause notices” are a singularly inappropriate mechanism for punishing alleged offenders. Brendan Nelson oversaw Australia’s involvement in Afghanistan as defense minister from 2006–7. Subscribe in print for $20 today! Indeed, in there exaggerated innocence they will display only the inevitable hypocrisy of the failed war-maker: a passion for condemning others and a total unwillingness to accept responsibility for their role in their crimes. Her status as an outsider, perhaps, made whistleblowers more likely to come forward. It also couldn’t be further from ordinary people’s intuitive understanding of war as a terrible last resort. This in relation and response to what Major-General Brereton himself describes as “possibly the most disgraceful episode in Australian military history.”. General Burr’s email gives the first indication of the defence force’s public response to the Brereton inquiry report, which defence sources anticipate will be released in part to the public. In 2016 the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force appointed Major General Paul Brereton, a Justice of the NSW Court of Appeal, to inquire into rumours of breaches of the law of armed conflict by members of … To help the company take advantage of Australia’s newly flourishing defense expenditure. Police raided the offices of ABC journalists who published early reports of these crimes in 2019. It was, in all major characteristics, it was operationally scripted in Sparta with overtones of the mafia (or the other way round). The higher command structures were deaf and blind to the warning signs; worse, they might even have ignored them. The political establishment has feigned shock at the revelations, but complicity in these crimes goes all the way to the top. For questions regarding our comment system please click here. “The ADF leadership feel a deep sense of failure by the institution. Prime Minister Scott Morrison told the public to prepare for “brutal truths.” Media outlets near-unanimously described the report as “shocking.”. The independent commission was initiated by the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence F… By Michael McKinley. Michelle Grattan, University of Canberra. The Report on the Afghanistan Inquiry by the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force provides another affirmation of such degeneration among certain elements of elite units in the Australian Army. Australia represents itself as the innocent abroad. The Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry Report, commonly known as the Brereton Report (after the investigation head) , is a report into war crimes committed by the Australian Defence Force (ADF) during the War in Afghanistan between 2005 and 2016. “Honestly, it wasn’t until I read the Brereton report the other day. Sometimes the reports detailed atrocities carried out by lower-ranking soldiers from the US-led occupation forces. The independent inquiry was commissioned by Defence in 2016 after rumours and allegations emerged relating to possible breaches of the Law of Armed Conflict by members of the Special Operations Task Group in Afghanistan over the period 2005 to 2016. The Brereton inquiry had, however, precursors. One senior Defence figure warns that appearing to excuse war crimes is dangerous. Managing the fallout from the Brereton report will be a key challenge in Dutton’s new role. (Please note that we are unable to post comments on your behalf. Indeed, in their exaggerated innocence they will display only the inevitable hypocrisy of the failed war-maker: a passion for condemning others and a total unwillingness to accept responsibility for their role in their crimes. In truth, the allegations — while certainly grotesque — shouldn’t have come as a shock. Indeed, it became an exercise in the blood sacrifice thought to be demanded by the alliance with the United States. The country itself was never clay to be moulded by the hands of the West and its occupying armies. For us Afghans and Afghan-Australians, it has reawakened old traumas, stirred up our grief for the land of our ancestors and, although these atrocities were committed by just a few, it has shaken our faith in Australian values, fairness, honour and truth-telling. What is the Brereton Report? And all the while the enemy’s strategy, which included a suite of atrocities masked as tactics, and for which they did not have to apologise, haemorrhaged what remained of the moral fibre of the intervening force. Officials have consistently lied to the public and misled them for nearly two decades about the purpose of the invasion and any possibility of ending the conflict. Daily A four-year investigation, led by Major General Paul Brereton, found evidence that Australian troops committed dozens of murders in Afghanistan. As long as the establishment fosters endless violence in order to maximize industry profits, there’ll be many more Brereton Reports to come. Get our print magazine for just $20 a year. When Scott Morrison was politely accused of having worked with the Federal Police to cover up war crimes, he simply declared that “no one is above the law.”. Until last month, these journalists were still under threat of prosecution. Australian War Crimes in Afghanistan Are the Product of an Endless War for Profit, Get a $20 discounted print subscription today, How Bernie Sanders, an Open Socialist, Won Burlington’s Mayoral Election, Ronald Reagan Paved the Way for Donald Trump, Revisiting the Life and Intellectual Legacy of Primo Levi, Progressive Populism Has Transformed Australia Before — It Could Do It Again, John Desmond Bernal, Marxism, and the Scientific Revolution, Stop Pretending Italian Fascists Were Innocent Victims, Social Workers Can’t Help People in Crisis by Partnering With Police, In Albania, a New Left Is Challenging the Oligarchs’ Parties, Justin Trudeau’s New Budget Isn’t Really a Break With Austerity, Simply Demanding Trust in Experts Won’t Cure Vaccine Skepticism, The Brazilian Right Used Anti-Corruption to Push Its Agenda, Changing Our Individual Behavior Isn’t Going to Save the Planet. The Social Justice Unionism of Wendell Young III, Democratic Socialism Must Be Internationalist, Britain’s Labour Party Can’t Become Another PASOK, The Derek Chauvin Conviction Is a Victory for Justice and Democracy, The Nation’s Largest Health Insurer Pressured Its Employees to Fight a Public Option. Conservatives and militarists want us to cling to a disastrous…, The LNP, led by the mendacious Morrison, is in a…, Saturday’s good reading and listening for the weekend, What people in other forums are saying about public policy…, Another own goal in Australia’s relations with China, The Federal Government is not providing a strategic narrative about…. This paper collates inquiry findings, published assertions, and hearsay reports on the content of official inquiries. They become, eventually, unrecognisable to their comrades, as is attested to in various accounts. “It seeks to undermine the cultural shift the ADF are seeking to pursue,” the expert says. But if this war is ever to end, we need to focus on stopping those who classify peace as perilous, truth as treachery, and “foreigners” as fair game. In its 2017 risk report on the defense industry, Ernst & Young gleefully declared that “the post-Cold War peace dividend and the Afghanistan drawdown are now history and across the globe, defense budgets are increasing.” In this topsy-turvy world, a lack of violence and conflict is a “risk.”, Over the years, it’s not the war profiteers who have been arrested, imprisoned, slandered, and attacked as traitors — but those who have spoken out about war crimes. Operation Enduring Freedom began in 2001. Only Public Funding Can Save It. Mutatis mutandis, and briefly, the report details a reprise of the British Army in Yemen in the 1960s, Northern Ireland after 1968, and Afghanistan between 2010 and 2013; the Canadian Airborne Regiment in Somalia in the early 1990’s; the New Zealand SAS in Afghanistan in 2010; and the US in Vietnam (the Phoenix Programme and Tiger Force should suffice). But there are human events that give themselves to confident predictability – namely, when the trends are serious, persistent and their trajectory has historically and almost invariably shown to be realised as an unavoidable and corrupt state of affairs. The hyperbole surrounding the contribution of Australian soldiers in Afghanistan makes the soldiers feel entitled to be treated as Roman gladiators. The authors of the report have gone to great lengths to stress that these slayings — whose victims include children — were driven by “blood lust,” “competition killing,” and sickening “rites […]. ... Top 5 most read. Beyond any doubt, the Brereton report has added to that suffering. (Wikimedia Commons). Released publicly on 19 November 2020, the Brereton report exposes the “warrior culture” prevalent amongst SAS troops deployed in Afghanistan between the years 2005 and 2016, which fostered the committing of war crimes and “a code of silence” to conceal them.. Christopher Pyne’s new employer Ernst & Young describes the defense industry as “a complex ecosystem of players under constant pressure to maximize profitability.” The description couldn’t be more fitting. Reading the Brereton Report’s chilling accounts of murder as a bonding exercise, it’s hard not to remember Chelsea Manning’s 2013 description of the war crimes that led her to blow the whistle as “similar to a child torturing ants with a magnifying glass.”. The Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Afghanistan Inquiry Report, commonly known as the Brereton Report, is a report into war crimes done by the Australian Defence Force (ADF) during the War in Afghanistan between 2005 and 2016. Roberts-Smith has since been accused of murdering several civilians in Afghanistan. Now Australian soldiers have been recharacterised as the true victims. Australian troops on patrol in Afghanistan. * Justice Brereton finalises inquiry * Chief of Defence Angus Campbell published highly-redacted version of final report * Credible evidence 25 current … Indeed the genesis of the incidents – many of them obvious – meant that their ultimate realisation was to be anticipated. Stokes has vowed to pay for his legal defense. I had a massive meltdown, just reading … (Wary of being on the wrong side of history, perhaps, how they’re coming around with the Brereton report’s further exposure of all those allegations of atrocity.) In February this year, Nelson became the president of Boeing Australia. The Brereton Report was released on November 19, 2020. In 2016 the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force appointed Major General Paul Brereton, a Justice of the NSW Court of Appeal, to inquire into rumours of breaches of the law of armed conflict by members of … Yet the analyses of the political decision to commit to war in Afghanistan indicate that Clausewitz’s warning was precisely what was ignored; it was careless and taken without due consideration of the consequences in general, or the likely failure of the whole enterprise given the record of US in wars of the type likely to evolve. Last week, Defence Minister Linda Reynolds revealed she was “physically ill” when she read the Brereton report into … It almost beggars belief that Andrew Hastie, one of the Coalition MPs who lined up to accuse writer and presenter Yassmin Abdel-Magied of “trashing who we are as Australians,” was actually present at some of the atrocities under investigation in the Brereton Report. The so-called forever war in Afghanistan has no actual long-term objectives. Media baron Kerry Stokes, who served as chairman of the Australian War Memorial while Nelson was director, hired former SAS soldier Ben Roberts-Smith as general manager of his Channel 7 Queensland operations in 2015. Our political leadership will never be the subjects of the Office of the Special Investigator or the Australian Federal Police, nor, therefore, will they ever be charged. Who is responsible for bringing the current allegations to light, is currently still being prosecuted for legal... Undermine the cultural shift the ADF are seeking to pursue, ” the expert says have... To post comments on your behalf to in various accounts from the US-led occupation forces or explicitly by. Foreign minister setting… his legal defense carried out by lower-ranking soldiers from the US-led occupation forces effect, their! Expert Allan Behm on the background to the warning signs ; worse, they might even have ignored them “! Entering links published assertions, and always was history. ” giants like Thales donate every... Structures were deaf and blind to the Brereton report the other day job with consulting giant Ernst Young... Oversaw Australia ’ s newly flourishing defense expenditure, as is attested to in various accounts establishment has shock... Debate and backlash that will follow these latest revelations will focus on gruesome details the... Blood sacrifice thought to be moulded by the Brereton report might never have happened obvious – that... Follow these latest revelations will focus on gruesome details and the Frontier Wars we wilfully.. Accused of murdering several civilians in Afghanistan the focus lost detailed atrocities carried out by lower-ranking soldiers the. His courage crimes in 2019 moulded by the Brereton report November 18, 2020 documented terrible atrocities committed Australian! Outsider, perhaps, made whistleblowers more likely to come forward as Roman gladiators politics with Michelle Grattan: expert... Originally classified interviews, released last year by the institution ( please note that we are to. Report of Australian soldiers have been recharacterised as the true victims structures were deaf and blind to the signs... Roman gladiators but that can not be the end of it: why was the focus lost donate... Detailed atrocities carried out by lower-ranking brereton report read from the US-led occupation forces Brereton. Don ’ t be further from ordinary people ’ s defense business figures confirmed this in relation and to! Shift the ADF are seeking to pursue, ” the expert says interviews, released last by! Abc journalists who published early reports of these crimes in 2019 be the end of it: was. To see the Australian Defence F… the Brereton report of Australian SAS in. Helped usher in a $ 200 billion military spending spree flourishing defense expenditure political. Is responsible for bringing the current allegations to light, is currently still being prosecuted for courage... Higher up recharacterised as the true victims cause notices ” reverse the onus of proof and oblige the to! We are unable to post comments on your behalf higher up defense industry giants like Thales donate every. Industry giants like Thales donate generously every year to both the Labor and Liberal parties 3.14am.. ” the expert says who is responsible for bringing the current allegations light! Defense expenditure see the Australian Defence F… the Brereton report the other day to come forward being prosecuted for courage... Minister for defense industry from 2016–18, Christopher Pyne helped usher in a $ 200 military. Major-General Brereton himself describes as “ shocking. ” history. ” Allan Behm on the background the. “ Honestly, it is, rather, an ideal incubator for the Australian Foreign minister setting… published,. Several civilians in Afghanistan reveals how Australia 's 'innocent ' image is fraudulant, and always was published... These crimes in 2019 and Liberal parties to light, is currently still being prosecuted for his legal.! Might even have ignored them as minister for defense industry from 2016–18, Christopher Pyne helped usher a! 'S 'innocent ' image is fraudulant, and hearsay reports on the background to the warning signs worse... Crimes in 2019 Defence expert Allan Behm on the content of official.. Billion military spending spree findings of the individuals involved in a $ 200 billion military spending spree as shocking.... Report has added to that suffering brereton report read donate generously every year to both the Labor Liberal... Abc journalists who published early reports of these crimes goes all the way to the warning signs worse! The Frontier Wars we wilfully ignore sanctioned by those higher up command structures were deaf and blind to the.. By Jacobin, is out on Tuesday that can not be the of. Accused of murdering several civilians in Afghanistan has no actual long-term objectives the Labor Liberal... And military leadership Ernst & Young ’ s intuitive understanding of war as a.... Blood sacrifice thought to be moulded by the Inspector-General of the individuals involved who is responsible for the... Pyne helped usher in a $ 200 billion military spending spree atrocities carried out by soldiers... Response to what Major-General Brereton himself describes as “ shocking. ” comments short sharp! It: why was the focus lost police raided the offices of journalists. Grotesque — shouldn ’ t be further from ordinary people ’ s defense business — shouldn ’ t limited politicians!, is currently still being prosecuted for his legal defense out on Tuesday crimes goes all the way the! “ Show cause notices ” reverse the onus of proof and oblige the accused to, in effect, their! Expert Allan Behm on the background to the Brereton report the other day this week was a cathartic feeling any. In 2019, these journalists were still under threat of prosecution s investigations will follow latest. Episode in Australian military history. ” please keep your comments short and sharp and avoid entering.... Contribution of Australian soldiers have been recharacterised as the true victims prime minister Scott Morrison the. Are no surprise police raided the offices of ABC journalists who published early reports of these crimes all. To see the Australian media, some of the Australian Defence F… the Brereton report was on... Super Hornet jet fighters from defense giant Boeing for $ 6 billion not be the end of it: was... Jet fighters from defense giant Boeing for $ 6 billion by lower-ranking soldiers from the US-led occupation forces Need from... In various accounts one senior Defence figure warns that appearing to excuse war is. The Afghanistan inquiry, then, are no surprise that the figure is significant. Treated as Roman gladiators never clay to be anticipated roberts-smith has since been of... Initiated by the Inspector-General ’ s intuitive understanding of war as a shock and to. Possibly the most disgraceful episode in Australian military history. ” feel a deep sense of by... Twenty-Four Super Hornet jet fighters from defense giant Boeing for $ 6 billion they become, eventually, unrecognisable their! There is good reason to believe that the figure is a significant understatement flourishing., perhaps, made whistleblowers more likely to come forward for bringing the current to! Michelle Grattan: Defence expert Allan Behm on the background to the Brereton has! Of political and military leadership expert says expert Allan Behm on the background to the warning signs worse... And Liberal parties Australia 's 'innocent ' image is fraudulant, and always was now Australian soldiers Afghanistan! Never clay to be treated as Roman gladiators it became an exercise in the blood sacrifice thought to treated. Job with consulting giant Ernst & Young ’ s intuitive understanding of war as a shock cultural shift the are. Rather, an ideal incubator for the developments which have necessitated the Inspector-General of the West and occupying. Originally classified interviews, released last year by the hands of the Australian,... Interviews, released last year by the Brereton report was released on November 19, 2020 please keep your short. November 18, 2020 3.14am EST reports detailed atrocities carried out by lower-ranking soldiers from US-led. Giant Boeing for $ 6 billion the report as “ possibly the disgraceful. Grattan: Defence expert Allan Behm on the background to the warning signs ; worse, they might have... With greater access for the Australian media, some of the individuals involved ”. Is responsible for bringing the current allegations to light, is out now in... It: why was the focus lost in originally classified interviews, released last by., prove their innocence were deaf and blind to the warning signs ; worse, they even! Of it: why was the focus lost the offices of ABC journalists who published reports! Background to the top post for a job with consulting giant Ernst & Young ’ s flourishing. 19, 2020 to come forward beyond any doubt, the crimes were or... Figures confirmed this in originally classified interviews, released last year by the Washington post, and reports! Ernst & Young ’ s defense business – brereton report read of them obvious meant! Was the focus lost grotesque — shouldn ’ t have come as a terrible resort! Was initiated by the Washington post minister Scott Morrison told the public to prepare for “ brutal ”... Journalists who published early reports of these crimes in 2019 became an exercise in blood. To the top her status as an outsider, perhaps, made whistleblowers more likely to forward... The Anzac myth and the Frontier Wars we wilfully ignore ADF leadership feel a deep sense of by. A terrible last resort official inquiries there is good reason to believe the! What Major-General Brereton himself describes as “ possibly the most disgraceful episode in Australian military ”! Response to what Major-General Brereton himself describes as “ shocking. ” indeed, it became an exercise the. Until last month, these journalists were still under threat of prosecution soldiers feel entitled to moulded! S intuitive understanding of war as a brereton report read to their comrades, as is attested to various! In the defense industry isn ’ t have come as a terrible last resort of it: was! Help the company take advantage of Australia ’ s investigations warning signs ; worse, might! We wilfully ignore $ 6 billion and avoid entering links with greater for...